Why does the commandment to settle the Land of Israel matter when discussing territorial concessions?
According to Ramban's position as presented, the commandment includes both living in the Land of Israel and not leaving it under another nation's control, and it applies in every generation. The author therefore treats it as a separate obstacle to surrendering land. Megillas Esther explains its absence from Rambam's list by saying that it does not apply in the present era, whereas Avnei Neizer and Chazon Ish maintain that Rambam also recognizes its continuing applicability.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«The Rambam, however, does not enumerate this Mitzvah on his list of 613 Mitzvos;»
- Author
- RABBI MICHAEL TAUBES
- Source
- Parsha.net — Achrei63, p. 2