Is shame a consequence of reason? Why do animals have no shame, and where did Adam's shame come from?
The conclusion "reason is shame, and vice versa" is wrong. Animals indeed have no shame, but not because they lack intellect. Shame is first mentioned in Bereishit (2:25): Adam and Chava were unclothed and were not ashamed, and after their fateful error they saw they were naked and covered themselves (3:7). So shame does not depend on reason: even before the error, the first man's intellect was of a magnitude we cannot imagine. Shame is the awareness of a discrepancy between what is right and what actually happens; the greater the "distance" between them, the stronger the shame. "Right" a priori means absolute rightness — the laws of the Almighty — but in practice a relative one is often implied, defined by the norms of a society, which is why the same behavior or clothing is normal in one place and "shameful" in another. Adam felt shame not because of the lack of clothing but because he understood he had fallen from the spiritual level he should have been on; nakedness was merely the outward sign. Animals do no spiritual work, make no mistakes, and have no cause for shame. To grasp the Almighty one should develop not so much shame as modesty — shame is the consequence of modest behavior.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«Стыд — это осознание несоответствия, разницы, между тем, что правильно и тем, что происходит в реальности.»
- Author
- Хаим Аккерман
- Source
- Love Doing Good — journal-179, p. 6