Why didn't the woman who confessed grave sins to Rav Chisda die after he told her "prepare your shroud"?
The Talmud (Avodah Zarah 17) tells of a woman who practiced idolatry and came to Rav Chisda with a confession, saying that the least of her sins was that her elder son was the father of her younger son. "Prepare your shroud," Rav Chisda told her. But she did not die, and this means she had not truly repented. The Talmud does not question that only death can atone for the sin of idolatry when one repents; therefore the Sages conclude that her repentance was not complete and sincere — to die, she would have had to complete the process of repentance.
Quote from the source««Приготовь себе саван», - сказал ей рав Хисда. Но она не умерла. И это означает, что по-настоящему она не раскаялась.»
- Author
- рав Ари Канн
- Source
- Love Doing Good — journal-179, p. 4