How does Chida explain why Yaakov's sons did not consult their father before fighting Shechem?
Chida cites the explanation that a completely obvious matter does not count as issuing a halachic ruling in one's teacher's presence and does not require consulting him. In this interpretation, the brothers' words “such a thing must not be done” express their understanding that the matter was obvious, while “Mishar Moreh” hints at a straightforward ruling.
Quote from the source«דמילתא דפשיטא אין צריך לשאול את החכם כי אין זה נחשב לפסק הלכה»
- Author
- החיד"א
- Source
- ניצוץ אחד — ניצוץ אחד — Lech-Lecha 5787, p. 1
- Parsha
- Lech-Lecha