Why does the Torah mention the kohen and the judge separately, and when does a sage become a rebellious elder?
Rav Hagai Preshel distinguishes consulting bearers of tradition about what is forbidden or permitted from approaching judges to resolve property disputes. He also distinguishes a sage's explanation of the law from a court ruling binding on the parties. If the Sanhedrin has considered the dispute and an elder rejects its final decision while continuing to issue contrary practical instructions, he becomes a rebellious elder. Disagreement with an individual kohen or judge alone does not create that status.
Quote from the source«Ответы мудрецов не имеют статуса распоряжения.»
- Author
- РАВ ХАГАЙ ПРЕШЕЛ
- Source
- Fond Nasledia — offline 305 SHOFTIM 2022, p. 12
- Parsha
- Shoftim