Why did David ask when he would die if Adam had given him seventy years of life?
Rabbi Pinchas Hirschprung proposes that David did not know Adam had given him seventy years, since a person is not told when his life will end. He connects this with a possible explanation of the psalm’s description of a thousand years as a day together with part of the night: David knew that Adam had lived only 930 years. The author himself notes a difficulty—the psalm is called a prayer of Moses—and cites Tosafot’s suggestion that an individual verse in that psalm may have been spoken by David. This is the letter writer’s proposed interpretation.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«גזידה היא מלפני כי אין מודיעים קצו של בשד ודם»
- Author
- רבי פנחס הירשפרונג
- Source
- Hagahos HaRebbe — 5737-05 (1) יו"ד שבט תשל"ז-4, p. 5