A year ago we made aliyah to Israel and are experiencing disappointment and "spiritual degradation": segregation, cynicism, school problems. Should we perhaps leave?
The general unsettledness of the first years inevitably affects one's state of mind and adds dark colors; any move, all the more to another country, involves difficulties. Perhaps you need to accept that life in Israel cannot be a natural continuation of life in Russia: a different society, a different mentality (the East is strongly felt). There you saw Israel through the prism of holiness, and on arriving you saw the country in an unflattering light — yet you present your personal observations as the only correct view, and one year of residence is far too little to form an accurate picture. On segregation: have you heard of the "melting pot" theory, which decades ago deprived hundreds of thousands of immigrants of their right to their own identity? In time you will see that Jews show supreme unity in hard times; Israel ranks among the first in the world in the number of mutual-aid organizations — thanks precisely to religious Jews. The attitude toward immigrants from the CIS in religious school admissions would not be so prejudiced if the immigrants themselves showed fear of Heaven and respect for tradition — your family is a pleasant exception here. Reality is more complex than it seems, and the unpleasant phenomena are also part of it — all of us will have to work hard to fix this. We live in an unrepaired world, and it is precisely to repair it that the people of Israel were sent here; each person is valued by his contribution to the common cause. The Sages instruct us to view the world kindly and to judge every Jew by the principle of "kaf zechut," focusing on his good traits; Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev said that even when Jews fail to do the Creator's Will, they remain a wonderful, exalted people. Practical advice: find your place — your community, people you feel comfortable with; warm friendships will strengthen your family; adopt a stance of maximum humility and an understanding that no one owes you anything; think about what you can give to the Jewish people and to Israel — by giving, we become attached to what we invest effort in. You should not think of moving to another country: such thoughts are a path not to growth and creation but to destruction. The section editor adds: having surveyed many people who arrived in the last five years, he found that only a minority felt as you do, and after several years in Israel practically everyone's view of reality became more constructive.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«А вот, о переезде в другую страну думать Вам, на мой взгляд — не следует.»
- Author
- Михаэль Бергман
- Source
- Love Doing Good — journal-183, p. 8