Why does the red heifer remain an unexplained decree if it atones for the golden calf?
Rabbi Moshe HaDarshan explains the commandment through the image of a mother cleaning up after her child: the cow atones for the sin of the calf. However, the interpretation presented here stresses that the commandment of the red heifer was already given at Marah, before that sin. This explanation therefore does not reveal the original reason for the commandment, which remains a chukah—a decree whose reason is unknown to us.
Quote from the source«על כן נחשבת מצוות פרה אדומה כ"חוקת התורה" - מצווה שאין יודעים את טעמה.»
- Author
- מהרי"א
- Source
- ליקוטים וסיפורים נפלאים — ליקוטים וסיפורים נפלאים — Chukas-Balak 5786, p. 2
- Parsha
- Chukat