Why is the red heifer needed to atone for the golden calf if those who sinned had already died?
The Ketav Sofer, drawing on the Ramban’s explanation cited in the text, distinguishes between those who actively participated in the sin and those who sinned only in thought. The former died, while the latter still needed the atonement of the red heifer. Unlike other transgressions, an evil thought concerning idolatry is counted as an action. The article explains the nations’ question about the need for this atonement in light of that distinction.
Quote from the source«בעבודה זרה, בשונה משאר העבירות, הקדוש ברוך הוא מצרף מחשבה רעה למעשה.»
- Author
- בעל ה"כתב סופר"
- Source
- ליקוטים וסיפורים נפלאים — ליקוטים וסיפורים נפלאים — Chukas-Balak 5786, p. 1
- Parsha
- Chukat