Why did the Vilna Gaon describe savings gained through violating Shabbat as merely apparent?
The Vilna Gaon explains the Mishnah's word “כחס” as indicating that someone extinguishing a lamp on Shabbat only appears to be saving something. In this explanation, there is no real gain in Heaven's accounting, and what is acquired through the violation will be lost in other ways. The publication illustrates this with a story about someone who violated Shabbat to pick up a banknote and later discovered that it was counterfeit.
Quote from the source«לְׁ אַ חַ ר הַ שַ בָּ ת, כְׁ שֶׂ פָּ נָּה לְׁ חַ לְׁ פָּ ן הַ כְׁ סָּ פִּ ים, הִּ תְׁ בָּ רֵר לוֹ שֶׂ מְׁ דֻבָּ ר בִּ שְׁ טָּ ר מְׁ זֻיָּף.»
- Author
- הגאון מווילנא
- Source
- סיפורים נפלאים לילדים — סיפורים נפלאים לילדים — Behar-Bechukosai 5786, p. 2
- Parsha
- Behar