Why does Rabbi Shimon assess the same-day slaughter of a sacrificial mother and offspring outside the Temple courtyard differently?
In the Mishnah's account, the first slaughterer incurs the severest punishment from Heaven, while the second, if deliberate intent is established, incurs lashes: the second animal loses its eligibility for sacrifice because of the prohibition against slaughtering a mother and offspring on one day. Rabbi Shimon holds that the first slaughter, performed outside its proper location, does not count as shechita at all. Consequently, the same-day prohibition has not been violated, the second animal retains its sacrificial status, and the second slaughterer also incurs severe punishment from Heaven.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«И человек, который сделал вторую шехиту, также получит строгое наказание Небес.»
- Author
- раби Шимон бар Йохай
- Source
- Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№467 Недельная глава Цав, p. 27
- Parsha
- Tzav