Can one fulfill the obligation to give thanks for rescue by answering “amen” to someone else's blessing?
In the account of Rav Yehuda's recovery, visiting teachers thanked God for his rescue. Ten people were in the room, and Rav Yehuda answered “amen,” so he considered his obligation fulfilled. The Talmud explains that answering “amen” in this case is as though he had recited the blessing himself.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«А тот, кто ответил «амен», как будто бы сам произнес благословение…»
- Author
- рав Иегуда
- Source
- Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро глава Ки-Тиса, p. 19
- Parsha
- Ki Tisa