Why did Rabbi Asher give two boys’ names when asked what to name either a boy or a girl?
Rabbi Chaim Yosef Gottlieb asked what to name the child if it was a boy and was told Ephraim. When he asked about a girl, Rabbi Asher answered Menashe. Twin boys were subsequently born and named Menashe and Ephraim; the story shows how the meaning of the puzzling answer became clear after their birth.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«ר' חיים יוסף תמה על התשובה, אבל בסוף אשתו ילדה תאומים, ור' חיים יוסף קרא לאחד מנשה ולשני אפרים.»
- Author
- הגה"ק מביקסאד
- Source
- פניני הצדיקים — פניני הצדיקים — Tsav 5786, p. 17
- Parsha
- Tzav