Must someone who acquires temporarily ownerless land compensate the buyer who has already paid for it?
This concerns the interval between payment to a non-Jewish seller and receipt of the deed by a Jewish buyer, when the land becomes ownerless under the rule described. Authorities disagree about compensation: according to Rambam and other early authorities, the new acquirer must compensate the original buyer for the loss. According to Rosh, this is an acquisition of fully ownerless property, so no payment to the original buyer is required.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«בהפוסקים יש מחלוקת האם על הזוכה בנכס בתקופת ההפקר לפצות את הקונה המקורי ששילם עבורו.»
- Author
- חיים קאהן
- Source
- משא ומתן — משא ומתן — halacha-biz-weekly, p. 2