Must I pay for damage to a borrowed item if it is unclear when the damage occurred?
If the damage may have existed before the item was borrowed, uncertainty alone does not make the borrower liable; the person demanding compensation must provide evidence. This differs from a case in which the item was certainly damaged while in a custodian’s care, but the custodian does not know the circumstances and is generally liable. However, if the borrower believes the owner that the damage was absent when the item was lent, the borrower must pay.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«אמנם אם השואל מאמין למשאיל שהקרע לא היה בשעת השאלה, פשוט שעליו לשלם.»
- Author
- Редакция «משא ומתן»
- Source
- משא ומתן — משא ומתן — halacha-biz-weekly, p. 1