When should another Torah scroll be brought out after an error is discovered during the reading?
According to She’erit Yehudah, an uncommon, substantial error requires another scroll, since the defect discovered does not cast doubt on the other scrolls. With common errors involving full and defective spelling, replacing the scroll offers no such advantage, because the same problem may affect the others. The text presents a disagreement about spelling that conflicts with a rabbinic exposition: She’erit Yehudah considers such an error uncommon and requires replacement, while the article’s author argues that scribes can make these mistakes too.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«ולכן לא נרויח כלום בהוצאת ספר אחרת.»
- Author
- יהודה צבי בלוהם
- Source
- דרושים קדמונים — דרושים קדמונים — Lech-Lecha 5787, p. 5
- Parsha
- Lech-Lecha