Why must testimony in a murder case be eligible for the laws of conspiring witnesses?
Rambam rules that a person classified as a terefah who murders in the court’s presence is executed, but not one who murders only in the presence of witnesses. Those witnesses could not be executed as conspiring witnesses for seeking the death of a terefah, and testimony that cannot be subjected to that liability is invalid in capital cases.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«ו ְכ ָל ע ֵדוּת שׁ ֶא ֵינָה ּ רְאויּ ָה לַה ֲזָמ ָה א ֵינָה ּ ע ֵדוּת ב ְ ּדִינ ֵי נְפ ָשׁ ו ֹת»
- Author
- רמב"ם
- Source
- חתת פלוס — חתת פלוס — Lech-Lecha 5787, p. 36
- Parsha
- Lech-Lecha