If a righteous person’s son follows an evil path, does that mean the righteous parent is flawed?
This does not necessarily indicate a flaw in the righteous parent. Rabbi Yosef Biton explains through the kabbalistic process of separating good from evil that “the shell precedes the fruit,” applying this to Ishmael preceding Isaac and Esau preceding Jacob. A soul with a lofty origin can face an especially powerful evil inclination. Even the children of righteous people retain the freedom to choose between good and evil; otherwise, free choice would disappear.
Quote from the source«אילו היה מוכרח הדבר שצדיק מוליד צדיק ,הייתה הבחירה נעלמת מהעולם .»
- Author
- הרב יוסף ביטון
- Source
- Arutz 2000 — לך לך פ''ז ערוץ 2000, p. 2
- Parsha
- Lech-Lecha