How do the two explanations of asking for matnas chinom, an unearned gift, differ?
In the explanation based on Midrash Rabbah, a person’s merits remain significant, but the request is phrased as a plea for a gift. In the Sifri’s first explanation, as developed in the discourse, the person sees himself as having no merits at all and asks solely for an unearned gift. In this second understanding, va’eschanan is therefore distinguished from the ten expressions of ordinary prayer connected with human spiritual service.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«Without any consideration to any good deeds or merits and in his eyes he has no merits at all.»
- Author
- Rebbe
- Source
- הפצת המיינות חוצה — הפצת המיינות חוצה — 45. Voeschnan 5725 Rebbe's Maamor — Va'etchanan 5783, p. 12
- Parsha
- Vaetchanan