Об этом документе

Chabad Research Unit — why no bracha on saying the hagada pasach-- shabbos hagadol 5785

Выпуск: Chabad Research Unit — why no bracha on saying the hagada pasach-- shabbos hagadol 5785. Темы: не определены автоматически. (For example, we don’t make a blessing for the mitzvah of blessing Hashem for the bread we ate.) [over] 1 Page CR MDS Free Translation Leibel Estrin Bitzalel Malamud Bitzalel says “Hashem gave me the Rebbe and the Rebbe gave me Hashem” “Our Rebbe says that we should tell the nations that the land of Israel is ours as a gift and an inheritance from our Father the King and Creator of the universe” B”H shabbos hagadol According to our Rebbe, the answer of Alter Rebbe indicates that Kiddush is not an actual part of telling the story of the redemption. 2 Page CR MDS Free Translation Leibel Estrin Bitzalel Malamud Bitzalel says “Hashem gave me the Rebbe and the Rebbe gave me Hashem” “Our Rebbe says that we should tell the nations that the land of Israel is ours as a gift and an inheritance from our Father the King and Creator of the universe” And, in fact, the Tzemach Tzedek had asked his son, the Rebbe Maharash, the same question and gotten the same answer, “I don’t know.” Furthermore, the Alter Rebbe had asked the same question of his grandson the Tzemach Tzedek and received the same answer! Another reason, according to the Rashba, is that since there are no limits to telling the story of the Exodus, a bracha is not said because it’s possible not enough of the story will be told to require a blessing making it a blessing in vain. [Pasach 5718] We are left with a question on this story: If Kiddush is not “part” of the Haggada, then why does the Haggada announce the topics starting with Kiddush—Kadaish, Urchatz etc. His father, the Rebbe Rashab, then told him that when he was a boy, his father the Rebbe Maharash had asked him the same question and he had also answered that he didn’t know. And, in fact, all the talks and discourses delivered by the Chabad Rebbeim at the Seder are on “This is the poor bread” or later parts of the Haggada. Those of us poor in Daas would suggest that maybe Kiddush is part of the Seder, but it is not part of the Haggada which starts with Hay Lachma Anya. He answered the question that the act of telling the story of redemption is itself a blessing, and we don’t say a blessing on a blessing. The blessing of Kiddush on the night of Pesach includes a remembrance of the redemption from Egypt.

Издание

Chabad Research Unit

Дата

11 апреля 2025 г.

Страниц

2