Об этом документе

Meshech Chochma — h-chochmah kisisa 2024 — Ki Sisa 5784

Выпуск: Meshech Chochma — h-chochmah kisisa 2024 — Ki Sisa 5784. Темы: parsha_commentary. Поисковые термины: недельная глава, парша, parsha, פרשה, פרשת השבוע. For example, earlier in our parsha, Hashem commands Moshe: ‫ְּפּ ָסָל ְלְ ָך ְׁשֵׁנֵי ֻלֹֻחֹ ת ֲאֲָבָ ִנִים ָּכִּראֹׁשִׁנִים ְוְ ָכַָתַ ְבְ ִּתּ י ַעַ ל ַהַ ֻּלֹּחֹ ת ֶאֶ ת ַהַ ְּדָבִָרים ֲאֲֶׁשׁר ָהָ יּו ַעַ ל ַהַ ֻּלֹּחֹ ת‬ ‫ָהִָרִ אֹׁשִׁנִים‬ Carve for yourself two tablets of stone like the first ones, and I shall write on the tablets the words that were on the first tablets.1 Similarly, the verse in Chumash Devarim states clearly that Hashem wrote on the second luchos.2 How them, can our verses imply that it was Moshe who did so? Rabbi Immanuel Bernstein 2024 / 5784 MESHECH CHOCHMAH Parshas Ki Sisa Preparing and Writing the Second Luchos ‫ ַוַ ְיְִהִ י ָׁשׁ ם ִעִ ם ה' ַאְרְ ָּבּ ִעִ ים יֹוֹם‬...‫ַוַֹּיּאֶמֶר ה' ֶאֶל ֹמֹ ֶׁשׁ ה ְּכָּתָב ְלְ ָך ֶאֶ ת ַהַ ְּדָבִָרים ָהָ ֵאֵ ֶּלּה‬ .‫ ַוִַּיּ ְכְ ֹּתּב ַעַ ל ַהַ ֻּלֹּחֹ ת ֵאֵ ת ִּדְּבְ ֵרי ַהַ ְּבִּרִ ית ֲעֲ ֶׂשֶׂרֶ ת ַהַ ְּדָבִָרים‬...‫ְוְ ַאְרְ ָּבּ ִעִ ים ַלַ ְיְָלָה‬ Hashem said to Moshe, “Write yourself these words”… He remained there with Hashem for forty days and forty nights… and he wrote on the Tablets the words of the covenant, the Ten Commandments. Let us consider: All the earlier uses of the term “he” in our verse refer to Moshe, “He remained there… he did not eat bread or drink water.” As such, the words “and he wrote” would likewise seem to indicate that it was Moshe who wrote the Aseres Hadibros on the second luchos. This is moreover corroborated by Hashem‘s instruction to him in the preceding verse to “write yourself these words.” However, this understanding would seem to be contradicted by verses elsewhere, which explicitly state that it was Hashem who wrote the Aseres Hadibros on the second luchos. The Carving and Writing of the Luchos The Gemara states that had the first set of luchos not been broken 1) the Torah that each person learned would not have been forgotten, and 2) no other nation would have be able to dominate the Jewish people.3 The underlying idea is that the Jewish people at that time were elevated to such a high degree that connected them intimately with the words of the Torah and placed them beyond reach of the other nations. The result of this second stage of writing is mentioned elsewhere in the Gemara,4 namely, tha

Издание

Meshech Chochma

Дата

1 марта 2024 г.

Страниц

3

Темы: parsha_commentary