Об этом документе

Torah & Horaah — Fleischman-Bamidbar - Collected Insurance for His Customers Watch 5783

Выпуск: Torah & Horaah — Fleischman-Bamidbar - Collected Insurance for His Customers Watch 5783. Темы: не определены автоматически. And under the auspices of Beis Horaah in memory of Baruch and Bracha Gross Bamidbar 5783 238 c Question in Choshen Mishpot d By Rabbi Yosef Fleischman Question I fix watches and I carry insurance for my store and all of its contents, both mine and my customers’. discussed in the Mishna (BM 80B) which Since you had the status of a shomeir sochor rules that craftsmen have the status of a it is correct that you are not liable for his shomeir sochor on the objects on which watch since a shomeir sochor is not liable that they perform work. Yosi who The Rosh and others (Tosafos Shantz, explains that he disagrees because, “How Nimukei Yosef) write that the correct can B engage in business with A’s animal?” interpretation is that when B lent A’s 2 Questions in all areas of halacha can be submitted to the rabbanim of our Beis Horaah at www.dinonline.org animal to C he assumed the legal status from the ruling of R. a renter sublets his rental for more than Even though A did not ask B to lend the the amount he pays, then if the renter was animal to C (and may have even been allowed to sublet he can keep the entire totally unaware), nevertheless the proper rent that he received from his renter. However, if he was A’s animal.) not permitted to sublet then the one who Therefore, when C received A’s animal as a really rented to the new tenant is the owner borrower, his relationship was not that of a of the apartment since the renter did not borrower from B but rather of a borrower have the right to rent the apartment. obligation to the owner of the watch and the only reason they paid you is because Thus, it is not because B is not entitled to you paid them to insure the contents of earn money from A’s property that A and your store, it seems that you are entitled not B is entitled to the money that C must to keep whatever they paid you. He does not However, in case it is customary for cite the Rishonim as we did, but argues that watchmakers to insure watches that are the ruling of Rav Yosi only applies to a case brought to them to fix, you must give the like lending an animal where the renter money to the owner of the watch. carry insurance for personal injury, if A, due to totally unforeseen circumstances, The Maharash Angel (6, 103) was aske

Издание

Torah & Horaah

Дата

19 мая 2023 г.

Страниц

4