Other — Page 16
Questions and answers on this topic, extracted from Jewish publications. Every answer names its author and the issue it comes from.
6,848 entries
Why does the Megillah end by mentioning the chronicles of the kings of Media and Persia?
Reb Yechezkel Abramsky explains that the chronicles are the place to look for the history of Mordechai’s governmental achievements. Mentioning them emphasizes that the Megillah’s purpose is to teach something beyond a historical account.
Reb Yechezkel AbramskyOtherRead more
Source: Torah Wellsprings — Purim Booklet, p. 30 · open and download the PDF
How does the author explain the Sages’ description of Esther as “karka olam”?
The author understands this as Esther’s lack of inner participation in what was happening, even without physical resistance. In the note, he connects this to the Talmudic discussion of coercion and distinguishes an imposed bodily experience from a woman’s inner participation in an act. This presents his particular interpretation of Esther’s situation and the sources cited.
Source: Other — קונטרס פורים ישיבת עוד יוסף חי תשפו קל, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
Why is it initially unclear what the king said to the sages in the account of Vashti?
The author explains that verses can present several aspects of one living situation at once. The king’s anger already confronted the sages with the question of what to do with Vashti, even if he did not explicitly ask it. The wording therefore allows the question to be heard as the king’s address, his own thought, and the advisers’ thought.
Source: Other — קונטרס פורים ישיבת עוד יוסף חי תשפו קל, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
Why repeat in the Prophets and Writings something already stated in the Torah?
Repetition adds a distinct force: in the Prophets, the obligation of a prophetic command is added. Inclusion in the Writings adds the need to reinforce the relevant observances. Esther’s wish to have the Megillah included in the Writings thus brings additional reinforcement and further interpretations of its text in the Oral Torah.
Which long words are cited in the discussion of ten- and eleven-letter words in Tanakh?
In the story, the Bach’s daughter cites “והאחשדרפנים” from Esther as an eleven-letter word. The editorial addition notes that the Torah itself contains the ten-letter “ובמשארותיך,” but no eleven-letter word. Rambam’s example “למשפחותיכם” is compared with the Masoretic spelling described in the text, which omits the vav and has nine letters.
Редакция «שבת טיש»OtherRead more
Source: Shabbat Tish — שבת_טיש_פורים, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
What segulah is presented for receiving a favorable response to a request?
Rabbi Emanuel Mizrahi recommends reciting Psalm 47 seven times, then placing the back of the right hand on the forehead with the thumb closer to the nose. Next, one recites “Restore to me the joy of Your salvation, and sustain me with a willing spirit,” says the angel's name Uriel seven times in one breath, and prays that the request will find favor and kindness. The text presents this practice as a segulah.
הרב עמנואל מזרחיOtherRead more
Source: Arutz 2000 — תצוה תשפו ערוץ 2000, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
What strengths and difficulties does the author associate with people born under Pisces?
The author describes people born under Pisces as honest, hardworking, loyal, supportive friends, and willing to listen to other views. He also identifies changeability as a weakness. In his explanation, their shifting behavior reflects genuine internal changes rather than deliberate deception.
Source: Arutz 2000 — תצוה תשפו ערוץ 2000, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Why does the quoted talk say that Jews cannot relinquish the Land of Israel?
The quoted talk describes the Land of Israel as an eternal inheritance given by God to the people of Israel, the descendants of Avraham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov. It concludes that no one can take it from them and that they themselves cannot relinquish it. The stated basis is the principle that a condition contradicting what is written in the Torah is invalid.
הרבי שליט״א מלך המשיחOtherRead more
Source: שיחת הגאולה — שיחת הגאולה תצוה עלון 1590-5786, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
What does the article call a genuine victory over an enemy?
The article attributes to the Rebbe the view that genuine victory means the threatening reality has ceased to exist, rather than merely achieving a pause or deterrence. In this view, lasting peace and security become possible once the enemy threat has been completely removed.
הרבי שליט״א מלך המשיחOtherRead more
Source: שיחת הגאולה — שיחת הגאולה תצוה עלון 1590-5786, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
How does the author advise responding if you hear the chant “Khaybar, Khaybar, ya Yahud”?
The author advises leaving immediately if this chant is heard. He interprets it as a threat to Jews invoking a repetition of the events at Khaybar and recommends learning to recognize the phrase in advance.
Редакция «Даркей Шалом»OtherRead more
Source: Darkey Shalom — Даркей Шалом Тецаве №23-5786, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
How should one view conflicting opinions in Torah?
The Shelah HaKadosh emphasizes the shared source of differing opinions and conflicting arguments. They were all given by one God and conveyed by one leader.
Source: Shabbat Tish — מידות_טיש_פרשת_כי_תשא 5786, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
How should one regard Torah heard from a scholar?
Torah heard from a scholar should be regarded as though one’s own ears had heard it at Mount Sinai. This comparison emphasizes reverence for the teaching being transmitted.
Редакция «שבת טיש»OtherRead more
Source: Shabbat Tish — מידות_טיש_פרשת_כי_תשא 5786, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Does someone who already knows Torah well still need a teacher?
The quoted teaching addresses even a great scholar. It emphasizes that studying independently is not equivalent to learning from one’s teacher.
Редакция «שבת טיש»OtherRead more
Source: Shabbat Tish — מידות_טיש_פרשת_כי_תשא 5786, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Can newly discovered ancient scrolls with different spellings overturn the received textual tradition of Tanakh?
The article explains that such discoveries do not, by themselves, replace the received textual tradition. The identity and authority of the scrolls’ writers are unknown, and the scrolls may have been put away precisely because they were written incorrectly. The received Masorah is presented as a tradition transmitted from generation to generation back to Moshe, in contrast to these uncertainties.
Редакция «לקראת שבת»OtherRead more
Source: Likrat Shabbat — לקראת שבת פרשת תצוה גליון א'י"א -5786, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
Why are the tablets often depicted with rounded tops?
The publication states that the tablets were square. It attributes their rounded depiction to the influence of Christian illustrators of Scripture.
Редакция «Субботний стол»OtherRead more
Source: Shabbos Table — Субботний стол Ки Тиса 2024, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
What does Shmuel’s prophecy add to a commandment repeated in Devarim if both are associated with prophecy?
Prophets have different levels and distinctive qualities, and Shmuel has his own particular stature. The discourse explains that these differences affect the force of a prophetic instruction and the degree of liability for violating it, even when the punishment has the same general designation.
Редакция «התוועדות»OtherRead more
Source: התוועדות — 27tisa5742 התוועדות, p. 26 · open and download the PDF
Why is Devarim distinguished from the other books of the Torah when interpreting adjacent passages?
The text presents two explanations from the Rishonim: one holds that the relevant juxtapositions in Devarim all meet the conditions for interpretation. The other attributes the distinction to Moshe’s arranging its passages himself, so their sequence was intended to yield interpretive conclusions. The discourse uses the second explanation as a basis for comparing Devarim to prophetic speech, while affirming that it was spoken with divine inspiration.
Редакция «התוועדות»OtherRead more
Source: התוועדות — 27tisa5742 התוועדות, p. 25 · open and download the PDF
Why does the subject of Amalek need reinforcement in the Writings if it already appears in the Torah?
Its appearance in the Writings does not weaken what the Torah has already stated. The reinforcement concerns the distinctive addition introduced in the Writings, which is not itself recorded in the Torah.
Редакция «התוועדות»OtherRead more
Source: התוועדות — 27tisa5742 התוועדות, p. 23 · open and download the PDF
Why explain the fourfold mention of Amalek if each passage already contains new laws?
New laws do account for part of the repetition, but the Talmudic statement under discussion emphasizes the repetition of the overall subject itself. It therefore calls for an explanation of the distinctive force each repetition adds to the commandment as a whole, beyond its new details.
Редакция «התוועדות»OtherRead more
Source: התוועדות — 27tisa5742 התוועדות, p. 21 · open and download the PDF
Can picturing one's teacher help with understanding Torah study?
Citing the Zohar, the article says that recalling one's teacher together with the wisdom learned from him can deepen understanding. The Arizal advises mentally picturing one's teacher when struggling with a Torah passage. Looking at a righteous person's face is also presented as an aid to memory, illustrated by the Chafetz Chaim looking monthly at a photograph of his teacher, Rabbi Nachum of Grodno.
רבנו האריז"ל; הרב יצחק בצריOtherRead more
Source: HaDibrot — הדברות כי תשה עלון 745-5786, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Why is looking at a righteous person considered beneficial even outside a lesson?
The article cites Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi, who connected his wisdom with having seen his teacher Rabbi Meir, even from behind. The Arizal explains that seeing leaves an impression on the soul: looking at something good allows a person to become attached to good. Seeing a righteous person is therefore described as a source of inspiration and added wisdom.
רבנו האריז"ל; רבי יהודה הנשיאOtherRead more
Source: HaDibrot — הדברות כי תשה עלון 745-5786, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
What surprised Tzvi Inbal about people who had spent many years studying in yeshivas?
Tzvi Inbal reported that yeshiva study had developed the abilities of people he met at least as much as technical education had developed those of Technion graduates, and sometimes more. In conversation, he was struck by their wisdom and mature judgment, which suggested extensive life experience.
Source: Fond Nasledia — Фонд Наследия Ки Тиса № 482-5786, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
What strengths and difficulties does the author associate with people born under Pisces?
The author describes them as patient, deeply sensitive people who can adapt to different circumstances and yield to others. He also associates them with avoiding difficulties, weak self-discipline, and difficulty putting their talents into practice. He presents their willingness to yield as a source of success.
Source: Arutz 2000 — כי תשא תשפו ערוץ 2000, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Why does the author attach importance to separate names for religious teachings that developed from Judaism?
In his polemic, the author presents Christianity, Islam, and Karaism as systems connected to Judaism in origin but distinct from it. He associates Christianity with adding the New Testament, Islam with retaining monotheism while changing the original teaching, and Karaism with rejecting the Oral Torah. In his view, separate names help distinguish these systems clearly and avoid presenting them as equivalent replacements for Judaism.
What do the chariots and bronze mountains in Zechariah chapter six represent?
The chariots represent God's messengers granting power to the kingdoms of Babylon, Media, Greece, and Edom. The bronze mountains express the strength and firmness of that power. The four spirits of heaven are explained as the kingdoms' heavenly representatives who received permission to rule.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»OtherRead more
Source: לשקד על דלתתי יום יום — לשקד על דלתתי_ויקהל-פקודי תשפו, p. 33 · open and download the PDF
What does the flying scroll in Zechariah's vision mean?
In the plain interpretation, it is a scroll of calamities, like the one seen by Yechezkel. Yonatan renders the phrase as a scroll flying through the air. The Sages interpret “afah” as “folded” and say that the Torah is written on it.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»OtherRead more
Source: לשקד על דלתתי יום יום — לשקד על דלתתי_ויקהל-פקודי תשפו, p. 28 · open and download the PDF
What do the seven eyes on one stone mean in Zechariah's vision?
The stone represents the Temple foundation laid in the days of Koresh, which seemed modest to the people. One explanation connects the seven eyes with a future sevenfold expansion. Another sees God's eyes here, expressing His attention and intention to increase the Temple's glory through its construction.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»OtherRead more
Source: לשקד על דלתתי יום יום — לשקד על דלתתי_ויקהל-פקודי תשפו, p. 21 · open and download the PDF
What does the expression “after glory” mean in Zechariah's prophecy?
One explanation understands it as a mission to increase Israel's honor. The cited Midrash explains it differently: God will first repay Esau for the honor he showed his father.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»OtherRead more
Source: לשקד על דלתתי יום יום — לשקד על דלתתי_ויקהל-פקודי תשפו, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
What do the rider and horses in Zechariah’s first vision represent?
The rider is explained as an angel, and the red horse as a sign of retribution against the Chaldeans, Media, and Persia through sword and blood. The horses following him are ready for God’s mission and survey the nations’ tranquility. The commentator explicitly says that he does not know the color meant by “serukim.”
Source: לשקד על דלתתי יום יום — לשקד על דלתתי_ויקהל-פקודי תשפו, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
Can an interpretation of Zechariah’s visions be regarded as definitive?
The introduction to the commentary stresses that Zechariah’s prophecies are deeply obscure, like dreams requiring interpretation. Certainty about their true meaning awaits the arrival of a “teacher of righteousness.” Meanwhile, individual verses are explained as far as possible using fitting interpretations and Yonatan’s translation.
Source: לשקד על דלתתי יום יום — לשקד על דלתתי_ויקהל-פקודי תשפו, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
Why does Haggai describe different proportions of loss for grain and wine?
The commentary explains that this need not mean wine suffered a greater curse: a deep wine reservoir is harder to estimate than a visible grain heap. It also cites Avot de-Rabbi Natan: wine should be plentiful, and damage to it is a bad sign for the world, so a larger initial quantity is used.
רש״י [?]; אבות דרבי נתןOtherRead more
Source: לשקד על דלתתי יום יום — לשקד על דלתתי_ויקהל-פקודי תשפו, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Why is studying only the Written Torah insufficient for observing the commandments?
The article explains that the Written Torah does not provide all the precise instructions needed to observe the commandments. The Oral Torah clarifies how to act in particular circumstances and distinguish good from evil. Its study is therefore necessary for bringing holiness into everyday material life.
Source: Chevrutah24x7 — 135 RUS EMOR Chevrutah24x7 #31 · open and download the PDF
How did Joe Dassin understand the purpose of a song and an artist's relationship with listeners?
Joe Dassin said that a song should help people live, and he valued the opportunity to make listeners smile. He sought to see individuals in the audience, notice their faces, and accept them as they were. When performing a song, he invested so much of himself in it that it became his own regardless of who had written it.
What regular studies besides Gemara were part of the Rebbe Rashab's learning schedule?
Each year, the Rebbe Rashab studied the entire Midrash Rabba, Chumash with Rashi, and an additional commentary on the weekly portions. Daily, he recited a chapter each of Torah, Prophets, and Writings from memory with an open book before him, and studied a chapter of Mishnah and a set portion of the Jerusalem Talmud. His schedule included reciting Zohar and Shir Hashirim before welcoming Shabbos during the weeks from Vayikra through Nitzavim. He studied Pirkei Avos slowly throughout the summer months, and on Tisha B'Av studied Midrash Eicha and the relevant discussion in Gittin.
the Frierdiker RebbeOtherRead more
Source: Chevrutah 24x7 English — 126 ENG PEISACH 5785, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
How did the Rebbe Rashab combine in-depth Gemara study with covering substantial material?
According to the Frierdiker Rebbe's account, the Rebbe Rashab maintained two Gemara study sessions: two folios a week in depth and three folios a day through regular reading. The daily folios were studied after Shacharis, Mincha, and Maariv, and he maintained this study even during the Yom Kippur break. He also studied halachic authorities, though not daily, describing his study of Choshen Mishpat as pleasurable and that of the other sections as accepting an obligation.
the Frierdiker RebbeOtherRead more
Source: Chevrutah 24x7 English — 126 ENG PEISACH 5785, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Which beings correspond to the different parts of the Temple according to Ramchal?
Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto explains that the Sanctuary corresponds to Jewish souls and supplies their vitality. The two inner courtyards correspond to angels, while the Temple Mount corresponds to the world’s material creatures.
Рабби Моше Хаим ЛуцаттоOtherRead more
Source: Mesilot — Месилот Глава «Vayakhel-Pekudei»-178-5786, p. 30 · open and download the PDF
How does the author of Or HaChaim connect the verse about ruling over animals with reincarnation?
The author of Or HaChaim interprets the word for ruling also as an indication of a sinful soul’s descent. He explains the sequence of fish, birds, livestock, and creeping creatures as progressively lower levels of reincarnation. The distinctions between these levels are connected with ritual purity and the requirements for slaughter.
Автор книги Ор а-ХаимOtherRead more
Source: Mesilot — Месилот Глава «Vayakhel-Pekudei»-178-5786, p. 26 · open and download the PDF
Why do people so often mock politicians?
Mendel Berlin explains that people are disappointed by politicians’ conduct, hypocrisy, and unfair treatment of citizens. Drawing on George Orwell’s observation, he adds that humor disrupts the established order and subconsciously strips authority figures of their aura of power and control.
Source: Chevrutah 24x7 English — 61 ENG VAEIRA Chevrutah24x7 #14 · open and download the PDF
Why did the Rebbe include so many source references in his talks and letters?
The Rebbe explained that references encourage at least some listeners to open the sources and thereby study additional parts of Torah. Even if only one person does so, including the reference is worthwhile. References and indexes make Torah study more accessible and are especially needed during the spiritual darkness of exile.
Source: Chevrutah 24x7 English — 103 ENG Noah Chevrutah24x7 #2, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Which additional commandments did Amram receive in Egypt?
Rambam writes that Amram received additional commandments in Egypt but does not specify what they were. The Midrash HaChefetz cited here identifies two: marriage and divorce.
Source: מסילות אל הנפש — 5786-438-מסילות אל נפש ויקהל פקודי, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
Why should stories in the Gemara be treated as guidance for our own lives?
The Lubavitcher Rebbe explains that not everything said in the sages’ study hall was recorded in the Gemara. What was recorded is intended to provide later generations with practical guidance for daily life. The account of Rabbi Preida’s patience therefore serves as an example for teachers in every generation.
הרבי מליובאוויטשOtherRead more
Source: מסילות אל הנפש — 5786-438-מסילות אל נפש ויקהל פקודי, p. 17 · open and download the PDF
How does death at the hands of Heaven differ from karet?
The publication describes death at the hands of Heaven as a lighter punishment than karet, while noting that commentators explain the distinction differently. Rashi understands karet as premature death and the death of one's children. According to Rambam, death at the hands of Heaven atones for a person's sins, whereas karet means the complete destruction of the soul.
Source: Shabbos Table — Субботний стол Ваякѓель 24-2024, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
In Tanakh, is a shekel a coin or a unit of weight?
The text explains that in biblical times the shekel served both as a monetary unit and as a unit of weight. Avraham weighed out silver shekels for the Cave of Machpelah, while the Book of Yechezkel uses shekels to specify a daily food ration. By the time of the sages of the Mishnah, the shekel’s value and appearance had changed.
Редакция «Субботний стол»OtherRead more
Source: Shabbos Table — Субботний стол Пкудей 25-2024, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
How does sincere literary fiction differ from an ordinary lie?
Yakov Shekhter locates the difference in sincerity: writing that comes from the heart reaches the reader’s heart. When the reader believes the author, an invented story acquires a persuasive power that can exceed the impact of actual events.
Source: STORY AT THE END OF SABBAT — Б А Б У Ш К И Н Ы С К А З К И, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
How do thought and spoken words relate to reality in Bakhya Katzenelenbogen’s reflection?
Bakhya says that a person is surrounded by many possible versions of reality, and a thought first fixes one of them. In his view, speaking that thought aloud fully materializes it, adding a new reality to the world.
Бахья КаценеленбогенOtherRead more
Source: STORY AT THE END OF SABBAT — ПОСЛЕДНИЙ ИСПАНЕЦ, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
What does “stretched out his legs” mean in the Mishnah's account of a father-in-law who did not pay the promised dowry?
In the discussion presented, Rashi offers two explanations: the father-in-law has nothing to give except the dirt beneath his feet, or he cannot pay even if he is hung by his feet. Rambam understands the gesture as walking away from his obligations, comparing it to the movement of the legs when walking. Meiri connects the outstretched legs with death and with the text's comparison of a destitute person to someone who is dead.
Раши, Рамбам, МеириOtherRead more
Source: STORY AT THE END OF SABBAT — ЛИЦЕМЕР, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
According to the text, why were fish not offered as sacrifices in the Temple?
The text explains sacrifice as the substitution of an animal's soul for that of the sinner when the person sincerely repents. Seeing what happened to the offering was meant to make the person recognize the gravity of the wrongdoing and repent. Fish are described here as having a lower level of soul that cannot fulfill this role.
Source: STORY AT THE END OF SABBAT — РЕБЕ ГОВОРИТ, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Is there a view that Job was not a real person?
David cites a view that Job is a literary character and that Moses wrote his book. This is presented as one opinion, rather than an undisputed statement.
Source: STORY AT THE END OF SABBAT — ОСЕНЬЮ В БНЕЙ-БРАКЕ, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
How does the story explain the significance of a recurring dream?
The text says that most dreams are empty illusions, but describes a recurring dream, like Pharaoh’s, as a small prophecy. The repeated dream leads the shochet to take the deceased Aizik’s demand seriously and seek the Maggid’s help.
Source: STORY AT THE END OF SABBAT — СИЛА СЛОВА, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Why does the Book of Esther refer readers to the royal chronicles for further details?
The commentary quoted in the article explains that a detailed account of events can be sought in the royal chronicles. The scroll selects events that help readers understand the world through divine purpose, ethics, and morality. The author paraphrases this commentary and tentatively attributes it to the Netziv of Volozhin.
Нацив миВоложин [?]OtherRead more
Source: STORY AT THE END OF SABBAT — МОЛИТВА ГРАФА, p. 5 · open and download the PDF