Halacha — Page 5
Questions and answers on this topic, extracted from Jewish publications. Every answer names its author and the issue it comes from.
72,282 entries
Why does iron disqualify altar stones?
The altar is intended to prolong human life, while iron is associated with shortening it. Iron must therefore not touch altar stones, even when the particular tool has never been used to kill. Contact with iron alone disqualifies the stone.
HaGaon HaRav Avigdor NebenzahlHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah61, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Can an existing building become the Temple, or can stones prepared for a synagogue be used for it?
The Temple must be built from the outset for Hashem and for the purpose of the Temple. An ordinary house cannot first be built and then converted into the Temple. Even quarrying the stones requires the appropriate intention, so stones prepared for a synagogue cannot be used.
HaGaon HaRav Avigdor NebenzahlHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah61, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Is bringing an offering enough to obtain atonement?
As the article presents Rambam's teaching, offerings atone only when the sinner has done teshuvah. Bringing an offering does not replace repentance. Teshuvah therefore stands at the heart of the Mishkan and its offerings.
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah61, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
Why is the etrog held with its pitom upward when it hangs downward on the tree?
When the etrog first emerges from the flower, it points upward. Only later does the fruit's weight make it droop with its pitom downward. Holding it with the pitom upward therefore follows its original direction of growth.
RABBI MARC PENNERHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah61, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
How can you bless the four species before fulfilling the mitzvah if you are already holding them?
One method offered by Tosafot is to hold the etrog upside down while reciting the blessing. The mitzvah requires holding the species in the direction in which they grow, so it has not yet been fulfilled in that position. After the blessing, the etrog is turned upright.
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah61, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
May I read general news on Shabbos if it has no bearing on my finances or shopping?
The text presents a dispute: many authorities prohibit this reading under the rabbinic restriction on nonbusiness documents, while others permit it if the reader enjoys it. It notes that Mishnah Berurah does not support that lenient position. Some authorities strongly discourage newspapers even when particular sections may be permissible, because forbidden material is difficult to avoid; others permit reading with a conscious effort to avoid those sections.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
May I read Torah articles on Shabbos in a newspaper that also contains forbidden sections?
Torah material may be read, including articles on the weekly portion, halachah, mussar, Jewish outlook, and stories and pictures of Torah sages. Stories that strengthen Torah learning, good character, and fear of Heaven are also permitted. The reader must make a conscious effort to avoid the newspaper’s forbidden sections.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
May I read distressing accounts of tragedies on Shabbos?
The text prohibits reading accounts of personal or public tragedies, death notices, or eulogies on Shabbos when they could bring the reader to tears. It also prohibits Holocaust accounts that sadden the reader and detract from the enjoyment of Shabbos.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
May I read advertisements and practical household advice in a religious newspaper on Shabbos?
The text prohibits reading business and classified advertisements on Shabbos, as well as business news that affects the reader’s finances or shopping needs or plans. It also prohibits consumer columns, gardening and housekeeping advice, recipes, and cooking instructions. The fact that the newspaper serves a religious community does not change this ruling.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
In what exceptional cases may utensils be changed from meat to dairy use or vice versa?
The text lists exceptions when circumstances are pressing and no other dishes are available, when a utensil has become nonkosher and requires hagalah anyway, when it is being koshered for Pesach, when it has not been used for twelve months, or when it is being sold or given away. It also permits deliberately rendering a utensil nonkosher in order to kosher it and change its designation. Another exception is koshering a meat or dairy utensil for pareve use, even if it will later be used for the opposite designation.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
May one benefit from air conditioning that a non-Jew turned on after hearing that the house is hot?
Rav Moshe Feinstein prohibits benefiting from this cooling because that benefit was unavailable before the air conditioner was turned on. The author understands this as a case without grounds for permitting a direct request to the non-Jew. The author tentatively suggests that improving an already functioning air conditioner might be permitted, and permits benefiting from the removal of cold when it is switched off.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
When may one benefit from a non-Jew's work following a hint on Shabbat?
When a direct request is permitted, for example for a sick person's needs, benefiting from the result is also permitted. Without such grounds, an acceptable hint alone does not permit benefiting from something newly provided through the non-Jew's work. The text permits reading by improved lighting if reading was already possible, and sleeping after an unwanted light is switched off, since the latter removes an impediment.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Can hinting avoid the prohibition of asking a non-Jew to work on Shabbat?
A hint phrased as a command is forbidden when the action may not be requested directly. Simply describing a situation without a command, such as mentioning inadequate lighting, does not violate amirah le-nochri. This alone, however, does not permit benefiting from the resulting work.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
May a non-Jew be asked to open a refrigerator if its light will inevitably turn on?
A Jew may not open the refrigerator in this situation because the light will inevitably turn on, even without that intention. Most of the cited authorities nevertheless permit asking a non-Jew to open it. Rav Mordechai Willig explains that the request and agency concern the permitted action rather than its forbidden side effect; in certain cases, this permission should be used only for considerable need.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
May a non-Jew be asked to help a suffering animal on Shabbat?
The text permits asking a non-Jew to perform melachah to relieve an animal's suffering, such as milking it. The explanation is that the Torah-level obligation to relieve animal suffering permits setting aside the relevant rabbinic prohibition. One may therefore ask a non-Jew to summon a non-Jewish veterinarian for a suffering pet.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
May a non-Jew be asked to turn on air conditioning on Shabbat in extreme heat?
Dayan Weisz permits this on an exceedingly hot day, relying primarily on the view that completing an electrical circuit without a glowing filament is only rabbinically prohibited. Considerable suffering allows asking a non-Jew to perform such an act. Rav Mendel Silber particularly supports leniency when heat prevents Torah study or prayer, but emphasizes that the discomfort must be severe.
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
May a non-Jew be asked to turn on heating or turn off air conditioning when it is very cold on Shabbat?
The Shulchan Aruch permits asking a non-Jew to light a fire in cold countries when the house is exceedingly cold; if children are present, ordinary cold is sufficient. The basis is that everyone has the status of a sick or potentially sick person regarding cold. Rav Moshe Feinstein applies this permission to turning off an air conditioner left running when the weather becomes very cold.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Until what age is a child treated as sick for the permission to ask a non-Jew to work on Shabbat?
The text presents several opinions: Dayan Weisz gives an age of nine, Rav Eliezer Waldenberg six, and Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach two or three. Dr. Abraham S. Abraham suggests that the answer may depend on the individual child's strength. Practical guidance should be sought from one's rabbi.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
May a non-Jew be asked to perform work on Shabbat for a sick person or a child?
A non-Jew may be asked to perform melachah for someone who is bedridden or unable to function normally, even if the illness is not life-threatening. The Rama extends the status of a sick person to healthy children. The Mishnah Berurah limits this permission for children to situations of considerable need.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
What should be done if there is insufficient light in the synagogue for Neilah?
Rav Yechezkel Landau first requires asking a non-Jew to reposition the remaining lit candles so that their light enables the prayers to be read. Moving those candles involves the rabbinic prohibition of muktzeh and is permitted through a non-Jew in the circumstances described. Only if this is insufficient does he permit a non-Jew to light candles so the congregation can recite the Neilah Amidah; the Shaarei Teshuvah and Mishnah Berurah record this ruling.
Rav Yechezkel LandauHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
May one ask a non-Jew to turn on lights for a Shabbat meal?
The Rama records a practice of relying on the Baal HaItur's leniency in this situation, but allows reliance only in great need. The Mishnah Berurah cites the Shelah, who rejects reliance even then, and describes communities that ate the third Shabbat meal in the dark. Rav Yechezkel Landau and Rav Yosef Dov Soloveitchik likewise emphasize making every effort to avoid relying on this leniency.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
May one ask a non-Jew to perform a rabbinically prohibited act for mild illness or serious need?
Maimonides permits such a request for someone who is somewhat ill or in a case of serious need, and the Shulchan Aruch adopts his approach. However, the Mishnah Berurah cites the Eliyahu Rabbah as substantially limiting the category of serious need: it must involve bodily pain. Under this restriction, substantial need without significant physical discomfort is insufficient.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
May one ask a non-Jew to perform melachah for the sake of a mitzvah?
The Baal HaItur permits even a biblically prohibited act for a mitzvah; Tosafot permit such an act only for settling Eretz Yisrael, allowing rabbinically prohibited acts for the ancillary needs of circumcision. The Behag extends permission for circumcision needs to biblically prohibited acts as well. Maimonides permits requesting a rabbinically prohibited act for any mitzvah, while retaining the special permission involving biblical prohibitions for settling Eretz Yisrael. The Shulchan Aruch adopts Maimonides' approach as its primary opinion.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
May a non-Jew be asked to perform melachah for someone whose illness is not life-threatening?
For someone who is confined to bed or unable to function normally, the text permits a non-Jew to perform necessary tasks on Shabbat even when the illness is not life-threatening. This includes melachah prohibited by Torah law. A severe migraine is given as an example of such a condition.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Why was asking a non-Jew to write a deed on Shabbat permitted for purchasing land in Eretz Yisrael?
The Talmud permits asking a non-Jew to write a deed transferring property in Eretz Yisrael from a non-Jew to a Jew for the mitzvah of settling the Land of Israel. Most Rishonim understand this as a special exception rather than a general permission for every mitzvah. The author sees it as an expression of the exceptional importance of developing the Jewish presence in the land.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Does amirah lenochri apply only to Shabbat or also to other Torah prohibitions?
The Raavad allows leniency because he regards the Talmudic discussion as inconclusive and the prohibition itself as rabbinic. The Rosh and Maimonides, however, apply amirah lenochri to all Torah prohibitions. The Shulchan Aruch adopts their stringent ruling.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
May one order an advertisement in advance for the Saturday edition of a non-Jewish newspaper?
Rav Hershel Schachter prohibits paying for such an advertisement when it will be printed on Friday night, because the order effectively instructs a non-Jew to print on Shabbat. In his view, neither placing the order before Shabbat nor avoiding direct instructions to the printing staff provides sufficient grounds for leniency.
Rav Hershel SchachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
May one ask one non-Jew to ask another to perform melachah on Shabbat?
The Mishnah Berurah cites the Chavot Yair's lenient view as one that may be relied upon in cases of serious financial loss, but the work may not be enjoyed on Shabbat itself. The Chatam Sofer permits this arrangement when the request is made before Shabbat, while the Biur Halachah raises objections to that approach. Rav Yosef Dov Soloveitchik and Rav Hershel Schachter reject the leniency even in great need. The author therefore advises consulting one's rabbi for a ruling.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
How does Rashi explain the prohibition of amirah lenochri?
In one explanation, Rashi treats a non-Jew performing melachah at a Jew's request as the Jew's agent on a rabbinic level. In another, the prohibition follows from the requirement that Shabbat speech differ from weekday speech: requesting melachah is itself prohibited discussion of work. These explanations help account for distinctions between requests made on Shabbat, requests made beforehand, and requests through an intermediary.
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Is asking a non-Jew to perform melachah on Shabbat prohibited by Torah law or rabbinic law?
For a Canaanite slave, the text identifies an agreed Torah prohibition. Regarding other non-Jews, the Mechilta presents a view that the prohibition is biblical, but the accepted position, based on the Babylonian Talmud and stated by Maimonides, treats it as rabbinic. Maimonides explains that the restriction prevents treating Shabbat lightly and eventually performing melachah oneself.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
How do different degrees of holiness find practical expression?
Degrees of holiness have concrete halachic consequences. Only the High Priest could enter the Holy of Holies on Yom Kippur, whereas other kohanim could enter the Sanctuary daily. A similar distinction applies to time: certain activities are permitted on Yom Tov but forbidden on the holier Shabbat.
Rabbi Zvi SobolofskyHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah66, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
When does involvement in one mitzvah exempt a person from another?
Tosfos limit the exemption to cases where the second mitzvah would interrupt the first; merely wearing tzitzis or tefilin therefore does not exempt someone from other mitzvos. The Rashba citing Rav Hai Ga’on and other authorities extend the exemption to active preparation for a mitzvah even when the second would not interfere, but distinguish this from ongoing fulfillment such as wearing tefilin. The Ran holds that the second mitzvah must be performed if doing so requires no change to the normal performance of the first. The Rema cites this as practical halachah: if the first mitzvah’s normal performance would have to change, the person is exempt from the second.
TOSFOS; RASHBA; RAV HAI GA'ON; RAN; REMAHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah62, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Does forming a separate synagogue always violate lo titgodedu?
The article makes the answer depend on the reason for the split. According to the cited position of the Ritva, Rosh, and Meiri, there is no violation when both congregations recognize each other’s legitimacy; an oversized congregation may sometimes need to divide. Maharam Alshich nevertheless requires following the majority custom of a city that has an established communal custom.
RABBI JONATHAN SCHWARTZHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah62, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
When moving, must someone retain previous customs or adopt those of the new community?
The article presents conflicting opinions. The Ran permits dropping a previous stringency in a new community when its prohibition arose from custom, but requires retaining it when based on another prohibition. The Jerusalem Talmud requires retaining ancestral customs even where local practice is lenient. Tosafos hold that someone who has fully settled in a new community must follow its customs.
Ran; Yerushalmi; TosafosHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah62, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Do differing halachic rulings and customs in one city violate lo titgodedu?
The text presents differing approaches: the Rambam forbids establishing two courts in one city because of disputes and the impression that there are two Torahs. As presented in the article, Rashi excludes customs from this prohibition, while the Sefer Hachinuch permits two courts and distinguishes this from disobeying a city’s sole court. The Netziv associates the prohibition with differing halachic rulings rather than merely differing customs. Rav Yechiel Yaakov Weinberg distinguishes lo titgodedu in halachic matters from the separate prohibition against changing a custom in a way that causes conflict.
RABBI JONATHAN SCHWARTZHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah62, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
How is the commandment to build the Temple understood to extend beyond the Mishkan in the wilderness?
The Rambam defines building a house for sacrifices and the three pilgrimage festivals as a positive commandment. The Or ha’Chayim explains that the word “Mikdash” in the first verse indicates the general commandment for all times. The following reference to the “Mishkan” concerns the temporary sanctuary suited to life in the wilderness.
Rambam; Or ha'ChayimHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah62, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Do rules about suspicious conduct differ for a community and an individual?
The Ramo allows that conduct forbidden to an individual because it arouses suspicion may be permitted for a group, since an entire community is not normally suspected. This ruling is disputed; the Chasam Sofer limits it to a shared communal undertaking, rather than many people each acting independently. The example of a non-Jew building a synagogue on Shabbos concerns suspicion alone: the article explicitly notes prohibition for other reasons and gives no practical permission.
RABBI MICHAEL TAUBESHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah62, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Why should I avoid conduct that makes others suspicious of me?
Rabbeinu Yehudah HaChassid explains that someone who arouses suspicion through his conduct bears responsibility for observers’ reactions and, where applicable, their punishment. The prohibition against unjustly suspecting others therefore also calls for avoiding conduct that invites suspicion.
Rabbeinu Yehudah HaChassidHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah62, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Does the prohibition against suspecting the innocent apply to someone known to be wicked?
Rabbeinu Yonah, the Klei Yakar, and the Bartenura are cited as allowing suspicion toward someone known to be wicked. The Klei Yakar explains that such a person is presumed to have continued his previous conduct, so this does not constitute suspecting the innocent. The article is not intended to establish definitive practical rulings.
RABBI MICHAEL TAUBESHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah62, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Must I judge someone favorably if I do not know them?
The article presents differing approaches: Rambam prohibits suspecting someone whose conduct and motives are unknown, while Rabbeinu Yonah requires judging an ordinary person favorably whether familiar or unfamiliar. Kallah Rabbasi, however, distinguishes between an acquaintance, who should not be condemned without knowing the facts, and a stranger, toward whom suspicion is permitted. The discussion does not provide a definitive ruling for a practical case.
RABBI MICHAEL TAUBESHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah62, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Why is suspecting an innocent person considered a serious wrong?
The cited Gemara explains the affliction of Moshe’s hand as punishment for unjustly suspecting that the Jews would not believe him. Rambam lists suspecting the innocent among offenses that obstruct full repentance, since people often fail to recognize it as a sin and therefore do not try to repent. The article cautions that its discussion does not establish definitive practical rulings.
RABBI MICHAEL TAUBESHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah62, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Must ma'aser be given from a government rent subsidy?
Harav S.Z. Auerbach treats a rent subsidy as income for ma'aser even when it is paid directly to the landlord. Several prominent American rabbis disagree, comparing it to a noncash gift, from which ma'aser is customarily not given. However, the Brisker Rav ruled that someone who needs financial assistance and lives frugally should not give ma'aser; the author places most rent-subsidy recipients in this category.
Rabbi Doniel Neustadt; Harav S.Z. Auerbach; Brisker RavHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah63, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
May I set aside ma'aser for someone who will study Torah later?
Ma'aser may be set aside for someone who will study Torah at a later time, such as after marriage. The money must be deposited in a dedicated fund for safekeeping until it is needed.
Rabbi Doniel Neustadt; Igros MosheHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah63, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
May I buy sefarim with ma'aser if I lend them to others?
Earlier poskim permitted such purchases on condition that the books were lent to others. The article states that when sefarim are plentiful and readily accessible, this leniency should not be relied upon.
Rabbi Doniel Neustadt; Harav Y.S. Elyashiv; Harav S. VoznerHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah63, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
May I pay my children's tuition from ma'aser?
Many poskim prohibit using ma'aser for either boys' or girls' tuition because parents are already obligated to provide their children's education. If a parent pays more than the standard tuition, the excess may be paid from ma'aser. The text also cites lenient opinions concerning older children studying away in yeshivah; because of exceptions and disagreements, a rav should be consulted.
Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah63, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
May I use ma'aser to pay for mitzvot that I am already obligated to perform?
The general rule excludes expenses that one is obligated to pay independently of ma'aser. Thus, ma'aser cannot fund obligatory matanot la-evyonim or machatzis ha-shekel payments. For the same reason, children cannot use it for the basic expenses of a parent's burial.
Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah63, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
What should I stipulate to use ma'aser for purposes beyond supporting the poor?
When beginning to give ma'aser, one should undertake it beli neder, without a vow, and stipulate the right to allocate the money to mitzvah purposes of one's choice. Without that stipulation, the rule presented requires giving the money only to poor people, rather than, for example, supporting a synagogue. Even with the stipulation, restrictions on permissible uses remain.
Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah63, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Is there a leniency in kol isha regarding young girls singing?
Rav Moshe Feinstein and Rav Ovadia Yosef allow reliance, in a case of need, on the view that the prohibition does not apply to girls who have not become niddot. In the ruling cited, Rav Moshe allows this assumption for girls younger than eleven. He requires stringency for older girls because some become niddot at eleven.
Rav Moshe Feinstein; Rav Ovadia YosefHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah63, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
May a husband hear his wife sing during the period when marital intimacy is forbidden?
Pitchei Teshuva leaves the question unresolved, while Aruch Hashulchan and Rav Moshe Feinstein prohibit it. Rav Ovadia Yosef permits it, adding that one who follows the stricter view will be blessed. Rav Mordechai Willig ruled that a couple may rely on Rav Ovadia Yosef's lenient ruling.
Pitchei Teshuva; Aruch Hashulchan; Rav Moshe Feinstein; Rav Ovadia Yosef; Rav Mordechai WilligHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah63, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Does using a microphone make a woman's singing permissible for men to hear?
Rav Chaim David Halevi explains that a microphone alone does not remove the prohibition of kol isha, even if the listener technically hears an electronic reproduction. Rav Waldenberg's leniency applies only when the man does not see the woman. Rav J. David Bleich notes that no recognized halachic authority treats microphone use alone as grounds for leniency.
Rav Chaim David Halevi; Rav J. David BleichHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah63, p. 5 · open and download the PDF