Halacha — Page 19
Questions and answers on this topic, extracted from Jewish publications. Every answer names its author and the issue it comes from.
72,366 entries
Why is the Megillah not read on Shabbat?
Reading the Megillah on Shabbat was prohibited to prevent someone from carrying the scroll into a public domain. The text notes that nowadays only Shushan Purim can fall on Shabbat.
Rav Shlomo AvinerHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
May the main foods of the Purim meal be postponed until night?
The article cites the Mishnah Berurah’s caution that the main foods of the Purim meal should be eaten during the day. Growing excitement toward evening should not displace the daytime meal.
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Why should Shabbat and festivals have special clothing?
Shabbat clothing should be different from and better than weekday clothing, and festival clothing should be finer still when possible. The cited explanation describes Shabbat as Hashem visiting us and a festival as our visiting Him. Such clothing deepens respect for the holiness of the day.
the Rav z"tl [?]HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
May one eat before fulfilling mishloach manot?
Rav Shlomo Zalman holds that one should not eat before fulfilling this mitzvah, as with other mitzvot. Chazon Ovadyah permits eating beforehand but considers it proper to give the gift before the meal.
Rav Shlomo Zalman; Chazon OvadyahHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
When must mishloach manot be given, and must every additional gift meet its requirements?
The required mishloach manot is given during the day; the Mishnah Berurah allows additional gifts at night after daytime fulfillment. Chazon Ovadyah also permits further gifts without all the strict requirements after one valid gift. Torat Avigdor holds that all the gifts must meet the requirements.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Must challah be separated after collecting received baked goods together?
The text states that challah need not be separated when a large quantity of received baked goods is placed together in a basket or refrigerator. The explanation that follows is unclear, so its reasoning cannot be reliably reconstructed.
Halichot ShlomoHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Must challah be separated from dough that will be divided?
When the dough reaches the quantity requiring challah separation, an intention to divide it does not by itself remove the requirement in the case described. If the person does not mind the pieces touching, the text instructs separating challah without a blessing.
Halichot ShlomoHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Who can receive mishloach manot for fulfillment of the obligation?
A gift to a non-Jew does not fulfill this obligation. The text also cites a view that gifts between those observing Purim on the fourteenth and those observing it on the fifteenth do not count. Both restrictive and permissive positions are given regarding a recipient below bar mitzvah age.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
May a yeshiva student give a friend food from his cafeteria portion?
A yeshiva student may fulfill mishloach manot by giving a friend food received as his cafeteria portion. Its origin in the cafeteria does not itself prevent fulfillment.
Halichot ShlomoHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
How many portions are needed when a gift is addressed to a whole family?
When a gift is addressed to a group, such as a family, it should contain two separate foods per person. Under the cited instruction, two foods for the entire group are insufficient.
Halichot ShlomoHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
How much food is needed in a joint mishloach manot gift?
One opinion requires each participant to contribute the value of two portions. Another holds that a single valid combined gift fulfills the obligation for every participant.
Rav Shlomo Auerbach; Chazon OvadyahHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Are women obligated in mishloach manot, and can a husband send for his wife?
The main position cited obligates women in mishloach manot, although Pri Chadash disagrees. The text mentions relying on a husband’s additional gifts, but Magen Avraham concludes that a woman should be stringent and fulfill the mitzvah herself.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Must the recipient learn about the mishloach manot before Purim ends?
Aruch HaShulchan requires the recipient to know of the gift during the day, so one should ensure it is noticed before sunset. Rav Moshe Feinstein allows the case in which a wife accepts for her husband even though he does not learn about it on Purim.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Can mishloach manot be arranged through an institution and paid for later?
Sending through an institution and paying later fulfills the mitzvah. Deferred payment does not itself prevent fulfillment.
Halichot ShlomoHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Does a gift count if it must be returned?
A gift given on condition that it must be returned does not fulfill mishloach manot. The text explicitly rules out fulfillment under that condition.
Halichot Shlomo; Chazon Ovadyah; Yalkut YosefHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Should the two portions be given together and in separate containers?
It is preferable to give both portions at the same time. Ben Ish Chai cautions against putting different foods in one bowl because they might count as one kind, but other cited sources disagree.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Is the mitzvah fulfilled if the recipient refuses the gift?
According to the Rama, the sender fulfills the obligation even if the recipient refuses. Chatom Sofer and Pri Chadash, cited in the notes, disagree.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Must mishloach manot be delivered through a messenger?
Opinions differ on whether a messenger is necessary, and many permit personal delivery. Rav Yisroel Belsky advises sending at least one gift through a messenger to accommodate all opinions. A child or a non-Jew may serve as the messenger.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
What if the bird sent was found to be nonkosher or the gift was stolen?
If the bird sent is found to be nonkosher, another food must be sent in its place. If the mishloach manot was stolen, it should be sent again.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Can produce with the sanctity of shemittah be used for mishloach manot?
Such produce may be sent if the recipient is informed of its sanctity. It may also be used to reciprocate a mishloach manot gift, though one opinion says to fulfill the mitzvah with another gift first.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Does a food gift count if the recipient cannot eat it for health reasons?
The text cites an opinion that the obligation can be fulfilled with sweets for someone with diabetes, food to which the recipient is allergic, or unsuitable food for someone on a diet. This is presented as a view about fulfillment of the mitzvah, rather than advice for the recipient to eat those foods.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Can clothing, cigarettes, money, or Torah insights replace food in mishloach manot?
The main ruling requires food or drink and does not count clothing, cigarettes, money, or Torah insights. The notes cite permissive opinions concerning clothing, cigarettes, and money, including a view allowing clothing when a woman gives to another woman. No permissive opinion is given here for Torah insights.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Can one fulfill mishloach manot by sending meat to a vegetarian?
The text states that sending meat to a vegetarian does not fulfill the obligation. Such a gift therefore cannot be counted as fulfillment of mishloach manot.
Sh"t Rivivot EphraimHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Can a drink count as one of the two portions?
Trumat HaDeshen and other cited authorities count a drink as a portion like food. Chazon Ovadyah prefers two foods in consideration of another opinion; Kovetz Halachot states that water and seltzer do not count as a type for this purpose.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Does kosher food count if the recipient does not accept its certification?
According to the cited opinions, the sender fulfills the obligation when the food is kosher, even if the recipient rejects its certification or avoids it as a stringency. One explanation takes into account that the recipient could sell the food.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Can deli meat and sardines be used for mishloach manot?
The text permits deli meat and sardines. It also cites Rav Moshe Shternbach’s doubt concerning deli meat and foods that can last longer than one day.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Must mishloach manot contain only ready-to-eat food?
One opinion requires food to be cooked and ready to eat. Another accepts raw meat after proper slaughter; the Mishnah Berurah records both positions.
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Do bread or a filled pastry count as two portions by themselves?
Bread counts as one food, so another food is needed alongside it. A filled pastry likewise counts as only one food despite its filling.
Chazon OvadyahHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
How substantial should the portions of mishloach manot be?
Each portion should be substantial; the text presents the view that it should be suitable as a course in a meal. Some authorities require the gift to reflect the recipient’s standing, especially if wealthy, while others consider this preferable.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Must mishloach manot contain only ready-to-eat food?
The food should be cooked or ready to eat; canned food counts as ready to eat and is acceptable. The text also records an opinion permitting raw meat if the animal has undergone proper shechita.
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Do two pieces of the same food count as two portions for mishloach manot?
A single food cut into two pieces does not count as two foods. Fulfilling the obligation requires two foods; the text states that foods with two different tastes count as different foods.
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
When should mishloach manot be delivered?
Mishloach manot should be given during Purim day, not at night. It is preferable to give it before eating the Purim meal. One should ensure that the recipient notices its receipt before sunset.
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
How many people must receive mishloach manot from me?
The obligation is fulfilled by sending one Jewish recipient a gift containing two foods. Sending more gifts is praiseworthy. Once one mishloach manot has met the halachic requirements, additional gifts need not satisfy all its stringencies.
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
According to the view attributed here to Rav Yisrael Salanter, must someone drink again after sobering up on Purim?
Emek Bracha quotes Rav Yisrael Salanter as understanding the mitzvah to involve continued drinking and a state of intoxication, so that someone who sobers up must drink again. The article stresses that this is a novel interpretation and that the Rema does not understand the Rambam this way. The footnote also identifies difficulties in reconciling this approach with the wording of Rashi, the Tur, and the Rambam himself.
Rav Yisrael SalanterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
What if drinking on Purim might make me neglect prayer or another mitzvah?
Several authorities who permit intoxication nevertheless hold that it is better not to drink at all if doing so might lead to neglect of even one mitzvah, such as washing hands, grace after meals, or prayer. Kaf Hachaim adds that one should still drink a small amount of wine for the festive meal. Preserving mitzvah observance and acting for the sake of Heaven remain the governing considerations.
Rabbi Yehuda SpitzHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
Can one fulfill the Purim drinking requirement by sleeping after drinking wine?
As the article explains the Rambam, a person drinks and falls asleep, and while asleep cannot distinguish arur Haman from baruch Mordechai. The Rema combines this approach with drinking somewhat more than usual and then sleeping. The Chofetz Chaim, the Steipler, and Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach followed this practice.
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
How do commentators understand ad d’lo yada without requiring heavy drunkenness?
The article offers interpretations involving an inability to calculate the numerical values of arur Haman and baruch Mordechai, decide which miracle was greater, or recite a lengthy Purim poem correctly. Another interpretation concerns the inability to thank God adequately for the miracles of deliverance. These readings require less intoxication than a literal inability to distinguish Haman from Mordechai.
Rabbi Yehuda SpitzHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
Must one get drunk on Purim?
The article presents a disagreement: the Rif and Tur understand ad d’lo yada as requiring substantial intoxication, whereas Rabbeinu Efraim understands the story of Rabba and Rabbi Zeira as rejecting that ruling and prohibiting drunkenness. The Pri Chodosh recommends drinking only slightly more than usual to avoid transgressions; the Pri Megadim, Aruch Hashulchan, and Mishna Berura support this practical approach.
Rabbi Yehuda SpitzHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim77, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
Should a necessary halachic leniency be withheld because people might later treat it as the norm?
Rav Schachter acknowledges the risk that leniencies may be misapplied, but holds that under extenuating circumstances they should be used to enable people to fulfill a mitzvah. He cites permission to fulfill the obligation of hearing the Megillah by telephone during an emergency; the ruling is tied to those circumstances and is not presented as the ordinary practice.
Rabbi Hershel SchachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim81, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
Does an unusual crisis necessarily require entirely new halachic rulings?
Rav Schachter says that most of his rulings in the crisis under discussion came directly from the Gemara, the Shulchan Aruch, or explicit opinions he had heard from Rav Soloveitchik. Unusual circumstances do not by themselves mean that existing halachic learning offers no basis for addressing them.
Rabbi Hershel SchachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim81, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
Must synagogues wait for a definite threat to life before closing during a dangerous epidemic?
Rav Schachter explains that a possible danger, safek sakanah, is sufficient to prohibit synagogue attendance in such a situation. Although participants in the discussion initially favored keeping synagogues open, he maintained that waiting was unacceptable: one must protect life rather than rely on a miracle.
Rabbi Hershel SchachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim81, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
Can someone fulfill the mitzvah of hearing the Megilla with a hearing aid?
Hacham Ovadia Yosef permitted hearing the Megilla through a hearing aid even for someone who cannot hear at all without it; Rav Yisrael Bitan emphasizes this reading of his words. The article notes the difficulty of reconciling this with his prohibition on hearing the reading by telephone. However, speculation that he retracted the telephone ruling is not treated as sufficient grounds to depart from his published decision.
Hacham Ovadia YosefHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim81, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Can I fulfill the mitzvah of Megilla by listening over the phone or through a live video feed?
The text presents a disagreement: Rav Moshe Feinstein and other authorities permit such listening, while Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach and Hacham Ovadia Yosef take the stringent position. The article's practical conclusion is to hear the Megilla in person, but when there is no possibility of doing so, one may rely on the lenient opinion and listen to a live transmission. In that case, one should not answer “Amen” to the blessings; convenience alone does not justify this leniency.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim81, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Which blessings are recited before Megillah reading, and how do listeners participate in fulfilling the mitzvah?
The Megillah must be heard at night and during the day from a kosher scroll written on parchment. Before the nighttime reading, the blessings Al Mikra Megillah, She’asa Nissim, and Shehehiyanu are recited; according to Sephardic custom, only the first two are recited before the daytime reading. Listeners answer Amen but not Baruch Hu U’baruch Shemo. The reader must intend to fulfill the listeners’ obligation, and the listeners must intend to fulfill their obligation through listening.
Rabbi Eli J. MansourHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim81, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Is Al ha-Nissim recited in Birkat HaMazon if the Purim meal ends at night?
If the meal began during the day, the final ruling of the Shulchan Aruch and Rama is to recite Al ha-Nissim even when Birkat HaMazon is said at night. The text also cites the Rosh’s view that the insertion may be recited only when Birkat HaMazon itself is said during the day. The article’s practical conclusion follows the view that takes the meal’s starting time into account.
R. Daniel MannHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim81, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
May we begin the Purim meal late in the day and continue into the night?
There is such a custom: starting later allows time for the other Purim mitzvot, Mincha, and arriving guests. However, according to the Rama’s formulation, the meal should not begin too close to the end of the day; the main part of a proper festive meal should take place during daylight. It may continue after nightfall, and Ashkenazi custom permits this even in Jerusalem. The religious significance of the nighttime continuation is explained through the unity of the entire meal, the original celebrations continuing into the night, or the festive character of both days of Purim.
R. Daniel MannHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim81, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
Is a minyan needed when the Megillah reading is moved from Shabbat to Friday?
The obligation of Megillah reading can ordinarily be fulfilled without a minyan. However, when residents of cities that celebrate on 15 Adar read earlier because of Shabbat, the custom is to read only in the presence of a minyan. For a reading for women, the text specifies the presence of ten women.
Rabbi Eliyahu KitovHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim81, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
How is Purim observed in cities that celebrate on 15 Adar when that date falls on Shabbat?
The obligations are spread over three days: on 14 Adar, the Megillah is read and gifts are given to the poor; on Shabbat, the passage about the war with Amalek is read from a second Torah scroll and Al ha-Nissim is added to the Amidah and Birkat HaMazon; on 16 Adar, the festive meal and mishloach manot take place. Megillah reading and the transfer of gifts are avoided on Shabbat because of concern about carrying in the public domain. The Megillah reading is advanced because its text does not permit postponing it beyond the days of Purim, while gifts to the poor are advanced for their benefit. The meal is postponed to avoid combining two celebrations, and delaying mishloach manot also distinguishes these cities from others. Al ha-Nissim is not recited on 16 Adar.
Rabbi Eliyahu KitovHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim81, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
Does Purim merriment permit humiliating people in comedy performances?
The article rejects using leniencies concerning liability for damage during festive merriment to permit humiliating Purim performances. Those leniencies apply only when there is no intent to harm and no hatred; the Mishnah Berurah also states that the custom is not to exempt significant damage. They therefore cannot justify lashon hara, slander or embarrassing the person targeted by a joke.
Rabbi Avraham RosenthalHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim83, p. 18 · open and download the PDF
What is the status of prayers and blessings recited by someone completely unaware of their surroundings because of intoxication?
The article identifies this condition as the drunkenness of Lot and assigns the person the halachic status of a shoteh, exempt from mitzvos. In this state, the person may not pray or recite blessings, and doing so does not fulfill an obligation. After becoming sober, the person must pray again.
Rabbi Avraham RosenthalHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — TetzavePurim83, p. 17 · open and download the PDF