Is Yair HaGiladi in Judges the same person as Yair ben Menashe?
In the explanation presented, they are different people: Yair HaGiladi had thirty sons, whereas Yair ben Menashe had no children; some opinions also place the latter’s death much earlier at Ai. Yair HaGiladi could have been Yair son of Seguv if that Yair was distinct from Yair ben Menashe. His cities may have been the original Chavot Yair conquered by his predecessor.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«Yair HaGiladi»
- Author
- Radak; Abarbanel
- Source
- Parsha Halacha — Parsha Halacha — halacha — Matos-Massei 5783, p. 4
- Parsha
- Matot