Do a missing piece of an etrog and lack of beauty invalidate it throughout Sukkot?
The Mishnah Berurah explains that outside the Temple, an etrog with a missing piece is valid on the remaining days: the Sages did not extend this disqualification or the ownership requirement to those days. Defects involving hadar, or beauty, are disputed: Rambam and his school permit them, while Rosh and his school require hadar throughout all seven days. Rema follows the stricter view.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«דעת הרמב"ם וסיעתו להכשיר כמו בחסר, ודעת הרא"ש וסיעתו להחמיר בזה דבעינן הדר כל שבעה»
- Author
- משנה ברורה
- Source
- לענין הלכה — לענין הלכה — sukkos leinyan halacha lashon kodesh 5787, p. 2