Why does Rambam distinguish the sanctity of the Temple from that of the Land of Israel, and how does Raavad disagree?
According to Rambam, the original sanctity of the Temple and Jerusalem endures because the Divine Presence does not cease. Joshua’s sanctification of the rest of the land depended on conquest and ended when that conquest was lost, whereas Ezra’s sanctification through possession endured. Raavad challenges the distinction concerning the original sanctification and maintains that even the second sanctification of Jerusalem and the Temple was not intended to last forever, since a new, eternal sanctification awaits them.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«לפי שהיה יודע עזרא שהמקדש וירושלים עתידים להשתנות, ולהתקדש קידוש אחר עולמי, בכבוד ה' לעולם.»
- Author
- הרמב"ם; הראב"ד
- Source
- לשון קדשו — לשון קדשו — sukkos leshon kudshoy yiddish 5787, p. 9