Do Rabbi Eliezer and Rabbi Akiva disagree about which shelters the Israelites actually had in the wilderness?
Drawing on Rashi, Rabbi Eyal Giat explains that the disagreement need not concern historical events: the people were surrounded by clouds of glory while traveling and built actual shelters when encamped. The dispute concerns what the sukkah commandment commemorates: the clouds of glory according to Rabbi Eliezer, or actual shelters according to Rabbi Akiva.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«אך, בשעת חנייתם עשו להם סוכות ממש.»
- Author
- הרב אייל גיאת
- Source
- כתרי תורה — כתרי תורה — sukkos kisrei torah lashon kodesh 5787, p. 2