How can one prove that the Oral Torah was given by God together with the Written Torah?
Rav Zilber suggested to his companions the following reasoning: a serious instruction from a sensible person, a prescription or a manual, must be clear and unambiguous. They opened the Torah at random: 'this month shall be for you the beginning of months', unclear which month and by which calendar; 'a sign on your hand... between your eyes', made of what and placed where; 'do not slaughter the blood of My sacrifice over leaven', total confusion. Finally in Parashat Re'eh: 'slaughter of your cattle... as I commanded you', yet nowhere in the Torah is there a hint of how to slaughter. The Rav offered a thousand dollars to anyone who could find this instruction in the text within a month; no one came for the prize. If we believe the Torah was given by God, it is absurd to think He left something unsaid; so the instructions exist, in the Oral Torah recorded in the Talmud: the calendar in tractates Sanhedrin and Rosh Hashanah, the rules of slaughter in tractate Chullin.
Quote from the source«Месяц давно миновал, а ко мне за выигрышем так никто и не явился.»
- Author
- Рав Ицхак Зильбер
- Source
- Nasledie — ФОНД НАСЛЕДИЯ рава И Зильбера №406 Рее