How is Yosef’s dispute with his brothers connected with the disagreement about a teacher’s opinion and the majority?
The article contrasts two approaches: Rabbi Yaakov Emden derives from the chief judge’s special status that something of particular importance is not nullified by a majority, while Nimukei Yosef explains the order of speaking as protecting the other judges’ freedom to disagree. This is applied to Yosef, who viewed his exceptional knowledge as grounds for precedence. His brothers, in this interpretation, disputed both his superiority and the conclusion that superiority overrides the majority.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«הרי כאן מחלוקת גדולה בנידון מחלוקת בין רב לרבים, האם הולכים אחר הרוב, או שהולכים אחר הרב מפני חשיבותו.»
- Author
- Редакция «אמרי מנחם»
- Source
- אמרי מנחם — אמרי מנחם — sukkos imrei menachem lashon kodesh 5787, p. 36