Why is kiddushin invalid without two kosher witnesses, even if the groom and bride did everything and acknowledge each other as spouses?
Jewish law makes a fundamental distinction between the function of witnesses in financial deals and in kiddushin. In deals, witnesses verify the truth, who lent whom how much, and if both parties agree and one admits the debt, witnesses are unnecessary. In kiddushin the presence of witnesses is an integral part of the procedure itself: without kosher witnesses, even if the groom said the words and placed the ring and the bride consented, they do not become husband and wife. The reason is that kiddushin changes the status of the man and the woman, and this affects everyone else; for example, one who has relations with this married woman is liable to the death penalty. Such a fundamental change of status cannot take place without witnesses; which witnesses are kosher is discussed in Shulchan Aruch, Choshen Mishpat 33-34.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«С кидушин дело обстоит иначе, здесь присутствие свидетелей является неотъемлемой частью самой процедуры.»
- Author
- Рав Яков Шуб
- Source
- Nasledie — ФОНД НАСЛЕДИЯ рава И Зильбера №405 Екев