What if, on a festival that falls on Shabbat, I mentioned only the festival in the closing formula of the Amidah blessing?
If Shabbat was mentioned within the blessing, the prayer is not repeated because of the doubt, although another view holds that the obligation was not fulfilled. If the mistake is noticed within toch kedei dibbur, the full closing formula, “Mekadesh ha-Shabbat ve-Yisrael ve-ha-zemanim,” should be said; merely adding “Shabbat” is insufficient. If Shabbat was not mentioned at all within the blessing, one returns to the beginning of the prayer even if both Shabbat and the festival appeared in the closing formula. The text leaves uncertain the case in which Shabbat was mentioned only in Vehasi’enu immediately before the closing formula.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«אם בתוך הברכה הזכיר של שבת אע"ג שלא חתם בו אינו חוזר»
- Author
- ישראל חיים רובין
- Source
- איחוד בלעטל - צעהלים — איחוד בלעטל - צעהלים — sukkos ichud bletel - tzehlim yiddish 5787, p. 7