How did Rabbi Chaim Elazar of Munkatch respond to someone knowingly smoking on Shabbat?
He first tried to judge the man favorably: perhaps he had forgotten it was Shabbat or did not know that lighting fire was forbidden. When the man rejected both explanations, the rabbi said with a bitter smile that such a truthful person belonged in the world of truth. This was a sharp rebuke to someone openly admitting a deliberate transgression.
Quote from the source«לֹא ׁשָ כַ חְ ִּתי»
- Author
- רבי חיים אלעזר ממונקאטש
- Source
- Shabbat Tish — Shabbat Tish — שבת טיש — Naso 5783, p. 2
- Parsha
- Naso