Can we reject a great rabbi’s theological opinion without declaring the rabbi a heretic?
Ra’avad distinguishes mistaken belief from culpable rejection: a person may misunderstand difficult biblical or rabbinic passages while remaining committed to God and Torah. Rashbatz develops this approach, holding that someone who accepts the Torah and sincerely seeks to interpret it does not become a heretic through an error, even on a fundamental issue. This allows a particular opinion to be rejected as outside acceptable beliefs while the scholar himself remains accepted. Rashbatz treats knowingly denying what one recognizes as the Torah’s teaching differently.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«They try to understand it all and make a mistake.»
- Author
- Rashbatz
- Source
- Torah Musings — Torah Musings — Musings - Bamidbar 5783, p. 8
- Parsha
- Bamidbar