How does the Chayei Adam distinguish imitating idol worship from adopting a non-Jewish custom?
In the explanation quoted from the Chayei Adam, a practice used for idol worship becomes prohibited even if Jews previously performed it as a mitzvah. For a custom unrelated to idol worship, a distinction is made: if Jews practiced it first as a mitzvah, they need not stop. If it was merely a custom, this explanation requires discontinuing it even if Jews practiced it first.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«In this case, if we were first, we would not need to stop, if it is done for a mitzvah.»
- Author
- Chayei Adam
- Source
- BET Journal — BET Journal — 37.-BET-Bamidbar-V4.pdfRFSRFSRFS 5783, p. 10
- Parsha
- Bamidbar