Why did Cain’s repentance remove only part of his punishment?
In the midrash, Rabbi Yehuda says that repentance removes half a decree, while Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi says it removes the entire decree. To explain Cain’s case according to the second view, the article offers several possibilities: the exceptional gravity of murder and leading others into sin, or repentance motivated by fear rather than love. Another possibility is that Cain’s words were a prayer for protection rather than repentance; according to the cited view, prayer removes half a decree.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«תשובה עושה הכל ותפילה עושה חצי.»
- Author
- Редакция «לעומקו של מקרא»
- Source
- לעומקו של מקרא — לעומקו של מקרא — Bereishis 5787, p. 32
- Parsha
- Bereishit