Why did King David’s census lead to disaster if the people may have been counted through half-shekels?
Ramban offers two explanations that allow for coins having been used. According to the first, even this method is permitted only for a specific need, whereas David wanted to know the size of his population for his own satisfaction. According to the second, the permission applies only to counting men aged twenty and above, whereas David ordered a count beginning at thirteen. Ramban then cites the explanation in Berakhot: David did overlook an explicit scriptural command, as punishment for an inappropriate expression about God when speaking to Saul. The explicit language of counting in David’s story distinguishes it from the wording of the census in Bamidbar.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«לָּמָּ ה יִ הְׂ יֶה לְׂ אַ שְׂ מָּ ה לְׂ יִ שְׂ רָּ אֵ ל»
- Author
- רמב״ן
- Source
- Ramban in Yiddish — Ramban in Yiddish — 28 א שטיקעלע רמבן - במדבר — Bamidbar 5783, p. 2
- Parsha
- Bamidbar