Why do we still mourn so acutely for the Temple destroyed two thousand years ago?
The Torah itself gives the answer. Yaakov loved Yosef most of all; the brothers sold him and showed their father his shirt dipped in goat's blood. Yaakov believed them, went into mourning and was inconsolable for a full 22 years despite all his children's attempts to comfort him, until he learned that Yosef was alive. God grants consolation only when a loss is real and irreversible; if the person is alive, the grief of his loved ones does not subside, which is why the sons could not comfort Yaakov. It is told that Napoleon, hearing weeping in a Paris synagogue and learning that the Jews were mourning a Temple destroyed eighteen centuries earlier, exclaimed: 'If you have mourned your Temple so long, you will surely merit its return'. Only one who has lost irretrievably is consoled; on Tisha B'Av we are inconsolable because the source of our loss still exists. The Temple will be rebuilt: the Chief Foreman is in perfect health, and His crew of builders only awaits the signal.
Quote from the source«Утешается лишь тот, кто безвозвратно потерял.»
- Author
- Нахум Пурер
- Source
- Nasledie — ФОНД НАСЛЕДИЯ рава И Зильбера №403 Дварим
- Parsha
- Devarim