Can a sircha be removed from a lung so that the meat can be considered kosher?
A hole in the lung renders the animal forbidden even when covered by a sircha, a membrane or adhesion. Following Mar Yaakov Gaon, Rosh allows gentle handling and rubbing: if the material comes off and no hole remains, it is treated as mucus; Rema accepts this custom, and Shach specifies checking with water afterward. Rashba and Shulchan Aruch reject this permission, although Shulchan Aruch allows a formation that detaches merely when the lung is lifted, without handling it. Chatam Sofer and Aruch HaShulchan justify even the custom of peeling it off with a fingernail: in their reading of Rashi, the absence of a hole underneath establishes that it was mucus rather than a disqualifying sircha.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«כאשר יש נקב בריאות, בוודאי שהבהמה טריפה לכולי עלמא.»
- Author
- הרא''ש; מר יעקב גאון; הרמ''א; הש''ך; הרשב''א; השולחן ערוך; החתם סופר; ערוך השולחן
- Source
- הלכה בפרשה — הלכה בפרשה — Noach 5787, p. 1
- Parsha
- Noach