When must a judge decline to hear a case, and when may he no longer do so?
The words 'do not show favoritism in judgment' are explained by the Shulchan Aruch (Choshen Mishpat 7:7) thus: a judge must hand the case to another if a close friend or personal enemy of his appears before the court; both parties must be equal in the judges' eyes, and ideally the judge knows neither of them. The words 'do not fear any man, for the judgment is God's' point to another situation: a judge may decline a case if he fears revenge from one of the litigants, but only before he has heard both. If he has already reached a decision, he must pronounce the verdict without fear of man.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«Идеальный вариант — когда судья не знаком с обоими.»
- Author
- Рав Ицхак Зильбер
- Source
- Nasledie — ФОНД НАСЛЕДИЯ рава И Зильбера №403 Дварим
- Parsha
- Devarim