Can a creditor offer a debtor a sale and then claim that the payment was collected for an old debt?
When payment effects a valid kinyan, the creditor’s unspoken intention to collect a debt does not invalidate the sale, because unexpressed thoughts have no halachic force. When payment for movable goods does not yet complete the acquisition, withdrawing generally requires accepting the mi shepara curse in beis din; the seller may nevertheless retain the item as collateral for the previous debt. Some authorities hold that in this situation an unspoken intention allows the creditor to keep the money toward the debt without accepting mi shepara. Others write that payment acquires movable goods through commercial custom, situmta, in which case the rule governing a valid sale applies.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«If he does not want to accept that curse upon himself, he must follow through on the transaction.»
- Author
- Редакция «Business Weekly»
- Source
- Business Weekly — Business Weekly — Emor 5783, p. 1
- Parsha
- Emor