Why must a buyer sometimes pay when it is unclear when a defect arose, while in other cases the buyer may withhold payment?
The Sma explains that an apparently healthy animal has a presumption that it is not a treifah, which remains valid until proven otherwise. If it is found to be a treifah after entering the buyer’s possession, the buyer must prove that the defect preceded the sale; without proof, the buyer must pay even if still holding the money. Cheese has no such presumption because it will eventually spoil. Therefore, when the timing of the mold is unknown, the party seeking payment bears the burden of proof, and a buyer who has not yet paid may withhold the money.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«Since cheese will eventually spoil, it does not have such a chazakah»
- Author
- Sma
- Source
- Business Weekly — Business Weekly — Toldos 5783, p. 2
- Parsha
- Toldot