Why did the Maggid consider the tefillin in the story valid despite an apparent defect in a letter?
Rabbi David of Stepin objected that repairing the letter would violate the requirement to write tefillin in order. The Maggid replied that there had been no actual defect: in his explanation, improper prayer had created a covering over the letter. He said that he had only removed that covering and revealed the original letter, so the issue of writing out of sequence did not arise.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«הלא על פי דין אותיות של תפילין צריכות להיות כתובות כסדרן»
- Author
- רבי דוב בער המגיד הגדול ממעזריטש
- Source
- הילולא דצדקיא — הילולא דצדקיא — Vayeishev 5781, p. 4
- Parsha
- Vayeshev