Can conflicting testimony about kiddushin be compared to a doubt requiring an asham talui offering?
R. Yona proposes a comparison with conflicting testimony about eating forbidden fat: uncertainty can call for a corresponding action, in the case of kiddushin a get because of the doubt. R. Yosi objects that an asham talui can be brought even when a person merely fears that he sinned, so this offering cannot establish the status of disputed kiddushin.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«שאני אשם תלוי דאף אם ליבו נוקפו שאכל חלב מביא אשם תלוי»
- Author
- ר' יונה; ר' יוסי
- Source
- ירושלמי לישנא קלילא — ירושלמי לישנא קלילא — Noach 5787, p. 1
- Parsha
- Noach