Why does the reason a stolen lulav is invalid matter?
Avnei Nezer examines someone taking a valid lulav together with a stolen one. If the stolen lulav is excluded by the requirement of “lachem,” it does not count as an additional valid lulav, and the mitzvah is fulfilled with the other one. If its only disqualification is that it constitutes a mitzvah performed through a transgression, he explains that this problem does not apply here because the unstolen lulav already enables fulfillment; the resulting addition then prevents fulfillment.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«אמנם אם נוטל לולב פסול, וודאי שאינו מעכב, שהרי אינו ראוי כלל למצוה ואינו עובר על בל תוסיף.»
- Author
- האבני נזר
- Source
- המאיר — המאיר — sukkos hameir lashon kodesh 5787, p. 1