Why did rabbis disagree about reviving the wearing of tekhelet?
After Rabbi Gershon Henikh of Radzin proposed his identification of the chilazon, some authorities praised the discovery, and some wore this tekhelet privately. Others objected because of doubts about the identification and dyeing method, the view that the threads should match the garment’s color, concerns about innovation, and kabbalistic considerations. Although the author of Yeshuot Malko questioned the discovery, he did not demand that these threads be removed or consider quarrels justified, since dyeing alone does not invalidate threads used for the white component.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«אך רבים מגדולי ישראל התנגדו ללבישת התכלת, כי כלל אינו ברור שהחילזון שנמצא היא החילזון דחז"ל.»
- Author
- רבי שמחה בן ציון אייזיק רבינוביץ
- Source
- בינת ההלכה — בינת ההלכה — Noach 5787, p. 1
- Parsha
- Noach