When repeating an incomplete candle-lighting blessing, should both Shabbat and the festival be mentioned again?
According to Hitorerut Teshuvah, when repeating a blessing that mentioned only the festival, the preferred wording includes both Shabbat and the festival. After the fact, he accepts a second blessing mentioning only Shabbat, since the festival was already covered. The article notes that the analogy to making up an omission in prayer is disputed: Mateh Ephraim requires one complete prayer mentioning both, though candle-lighting blessings may differ.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«ובדיעבד אם בירכה של שבת לחוד יצאה יד"ח, כיון שעל יו"ט כבר בירכה»
- Author
- התעוררות תשובה
- Source
- אמונים נצר - קאסאן בית שמש — אמונים נצר - קאסאן בית שמש — sukkos eminim noitzar - kasan beit shemesh lashon kodesh 5787, p. 31