Why did some members of the Sanhedrin disapprove of Mordechai’s court service while most supported him?
The discourse connects this to differing approaches in the Babylonian and Jerusalem Talmuds concerning pious people whose service limits their study time. In the Bavli’s wording, their Torah is preserved: what they learned is not forgotten, but increased knowledge is not promised. In the Yerushalmi, their study is blessed, allowing knowledge to grow even with limited time. This explains why some saw Mordechai’s position as a loss for his learning, while others saw Torah and good deeds combined.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«In other words, not only does he not forget Torah, but his Torah knowledge increases!»
- Author
- The Rebbe
- Source
- Farbrengen With The Rebbe - Kovtzim — Purim 5733 — english, p. 17