How can a Torah scholar be in Gehinnom, and why must scholars be discussed separately from other sinners?
Studying Torah does not remove free choice, so a Torah scholar can also sin and incur punishment. The talk understands the two statements as addressing two forms of service: Issachar primarily studies Torah, while Zevulun engages with worldly affairs and mitzvot. One group's protection cannot automatically be inferred from the other's: Torah knowledge increases responsibility, and each group's protection has its own basis.
Quote from the source«מה הדין אפוא אם "חטא ופגם ועבר את הדרך"? – עונשו גיהנום.»
- Author
- כ"ק אדמו"ר שליט"א
- Source
- Farbrengen With The Rebbe - Kovtzim — 20 Av 5731, p. 28